Daily Archives: 24 April 2011

Swamp Thing 10 (May-June 1974)

15994.jpg

I love this issue. I only sort of remembered it, but I love what Wein and Wrightson do with it. Wrightson gets a story credit so maybe he’s the one who came up with the concept. Swamp Thing’s back in his swamp, basically just hanging around, when he comes across an old black woman. A very old black woman; she used to be a slave on a plantation nearby. She tells him a story about how the swamp is protected by the ghosts of slaves.

Then Arcane and his Un-Men show up and attack Swampy. You get a few pages of beautiful Wrightson fight art, then the slaves’ ghosts show up to save Swamp Thing. He sleeps through the fight; it happens unseen.

The issue has a dreamlike quality to it. It’s this haunting little story where Swamp Thing isn’t even the lead when fighting his nemesis.

Just wonderful.

CREDITS

The Man Who Would Not Die; writer, Len Wein; artist, Bernie Wrightson; editor, Joe Orlando; publisher, DC Comics.

About these ads

Swamp Thing 9 (March-April 1974)

15993.jpg

Wein and Wrightson (he has some amazing panels this issue, whether Matt and Abby at the beach or a captured alien) are back on task this issue.

While Wein still overwrites, the plotting is so good it doesn’t matter again. This issue brings Swamp Thinig back to the swamp where he was created and Wein nicely contrives to get Matt back there too. Swamp Thing’s back to work in his lab—it only occurred to me this issue all his adventures previous were out of his control; the delay is because Arcane grabbed him second issue—and he runs into an alien.

The alien’s using the lab to repair his spacecraft, which leads to some misunderstanding between him and Swamp Thing. The alien design from Wrightson is singular; it’s utterly brilliant.

Cable shows up with the rest of the government agents to contain the situation.

Compications ensue.

A great issue.

CREDITS

The Stalker from Beyond; writer, Len Wein; penciller, Bernie Wrightson; inker, Wrightson and Mike Kaluta; editor, Joe Orlando; publisher, DC Comics.

Swamp Thing 8 (January-February 1974)

15992.jpg

While the cover—Swamp Thing versus green tentacles—might be memorable, this issue is the first where Wein doesn’t come up with something distinctive as far as narrative. It’s Swamp Thing not versus green tentacles but versus a Lovecraftian god. A really, really weak one who lives in a mine and eats people to get stronger. Swampy takes him out with a cave-in.

Wrightson’s panels, on the monster section, are very strong. He draws a hideous creature and does the summary of its history well too. But the rest of the issue feels dispassionate. Swamp Thing shows up in town after fighting a bear. It’s not a very interesting fight scene, against the bear, in a cave. And then there’s a bunch of talking heads pages, only since Swamp Thing doesn’t talk, it’s rather boring.

It’s decent enough, but something’s definitely missing.

I mean, where are Matt and Abby?

CREDITS

Night of the Bat; writer, Len Wein; artist, Bernie Wrightson; editor, Joe Orlando; publisher, DC Comics.

Swamp Thing 7 (November-December 1973)

15991.jpg

Swamp Thing arrives in Gotham to save Matt and Abby from the Conclave and runs into Batman. Wrightson doing Batman is something, especially seventies Batman. I love Bruce’s hair, but how does he fit it into the cowl?

Wein finds a great way to integrate Swamp Thing into the DC Universe proper; for a while, as he’s roughing up thugs for information, it’s clear he’d make an interesting pulp hero (which later writers came back to, I think). Wein even avoids most of his regular missteps, maybe because Batman takes up so much of the issue, not Matt. There is one regular Wein moment when Matt’s proud he’s not answering questions under torture (even though he doesn’t know anything).

The issue resolves some of the questions so far—but not why the Conclave’s leader has a pet monkey.

The only serious drawback is Batman gets the conclusion, not Swamp Thing.

CREDITS

Night of the Bat; writer, Len Wein; artist, Bernie Wrightson; letterer, Gaspar Saladino; editors, E. Nelson Bridwell and Joe Orlando; publisher, DC Comics.

Captain America: Man out of Time 5 (May 2011)

808475.jpg

As Man out of Time finishes, it’s not clear if it’s the new continuity or if Marvel just gave Waid and company the chance to retell the Cap origin again. The series suggests it might behoove them to let other writers take a crack at it, because Waid does find a lot to talk about, a lot to look at.

This issue finally returns Cap to the past, something I can’t remember having read before. The future, it turns out, has spoiled him in a lot of ways. Waid does take the easy way out—he doesn’t give Cap an Edith Keeler (the disappearance of Bucky and Peggy Carter from the official record could be a sequel series in itself)—but it works. Even Molina manages not to offend too greatly.

Waid also addresses the question of Cap’s leadership, as well as those awkward reports.

It’s a good, thoughtful series.

CREDITS

Writer, Mark Waid; penciller, Jorge Molina; inker, Karl Kesel; colorist, Frank D’Armata; letterer, Joe Sabino; editors, Lauren Sankovitch and Tom Brevoort; publisher, Marvel Comics.

Captain America: Man out of Time 4 (April 2011)

moof4.jpg

It’s nice to read a Captain America comic where the writer isn’t afraid to be unabashedly liberal. Brubaker always keeps it on the back burner a little, like he’s not willing to alienate. Waid is willing to alienate.

This issue might feature Molina’s best art so far, only because at one point I thought they might have brought someone else—someone competent onto the book. They haven’t, but for a few pages it seems like they do.

Waid’s updating of Cap’s origin, if updating is what he’s doing here (it’s still not clear), leaves him far more alone in the present than any other telling before has done. Even the Avengers are just sort of a distraction for him, not something he particularly cares about (or leads—Iron Man’s the leader in Man out of Time).

It’s a strong issue, with Waid doing fine work. And the cliffhanger’s got potential.

CREDITS

Writer, Mark Waid; penciller, Jorge Molina; inker, Karl Kesel; colorist, Frank D’Armata; letterer, Joe Sabino; editors, Lauren Sankovitch and Tom Brevoort; publisher, Marvel Comics.

Captain America: Man out of Time 3 (March 2011)

791546.jpg

Once again, Waid broaches a really interesting possibility for Man out of Time—Cap going back in time to WWII via Reed Richards’s time machine prototype, but then he closes it down again.

Sure, it’s kind of cool to see Cap and Tony hanging out and the Martin Luther King Jr. stuff is excellent (I imagine it enraged a number of Marvel readers… oh, wait, I’m sure this series sold like crap). But Waid’s playing it really safe. He’s just setting the groundwork for what’s basically a movie template. He’s giving readers a modern Cap origin retelling—a good one—but it feels pointless other than as an Avengers movie precursor.

He’s got two issues to go, so I suppose it’s possible (if unlikely) he can do something special with the series. Still, making it good—Captain America: Month One—is an achievement.

Molina’s art, as usual, is the pits.

CREDITS

Writer, Mark Waid; penciller, Jorge Molina; inkers, Karl Kesel and Scott Hanna; colorist, Frank D’Armata; letterer, Joe Sabino; editors, Lauren Sankovitch and Tom Brevoort; publisher, Marvel Comics.